Beaver Island Real Estate

Beaver Island Real Estate

Welcome to Beaver Island, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Lake Michigan, within Charlevoix County, Michigan. Known for its breathtaking natural beauty and rich history, Beaver Island offers a unique blend of tranquility and adventure that captivates all who visit.

As the largest island in Lake Michigan, Beaver Island boasts over 13 miles of pristine beaches, lush forests, and scenic trails, making it a paradise for outdoor enthusiasts. Whether you’re hiking through the dense woodlands, biking along the shoreline, or enjoying a leisurely kayak ride in the crystal-clear waters, the island’s stunning landscapes are sure to leave you in awe. Wildlife abounds here, providing ample opportunities for birdwatching and nature photography.

The island is steeped in history, originally settled by Irish immigrants in the 19th century. This cultural heritage is celebrated through local festivals, art galleries, and charming shops that line the main streets of St. James, the island’s primary community. Visitors can explore historical sites, including the Beaver Island Lighthouse and the intriguing Marine Museum, which tell the story of the island’s maritime past.

For those seeking a peaceful retreat, Beaver Island offers a welcoming community with a laid-back lifestyle. The island features cozy bed-and-breakfasts, rustic cabins, and charming cottages, perfect for a weekend getaway or a longer stay. With its friendly locals and vibrant community spirit, Beaver Island is not just a destination; it’s a place to call home.

Discover the serene beauty and rich culture of Beaver Island—where adventure awaits and memories are made!

Newest Listings in Beaver Island

$1,050,000
4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 1947510 MLS ⋅ N/A BLDG.
Set on 5.2 private, wooded acres at the southern edge of St. James on Beaver Island, this home is a masterwork of western lodge architecture translated for Northern Michigan living. Built by island-renowned builder Ron Wojan, with steel-reinforced timber framing throughout, it was constructed to endure. Florida pine paneling, reclaimed lumber flooring worn to a rich, storied patina, and cedar-lined closets speak to a level of craftsmanship rarely found today. Each of the four bedrooms enjoys its own en-suite bath. A covered entry welcomes you off the circular drive. Out back, the true showpiece: a 12' by 43' screened porch spanning the full width of the home, anchored by a dining area on one end and a built-in grilling station on the other, made for entertaining against the island backdrop. Inside, custom cabinetry glows with automatic backlighting, and the home was crafted with Beaver Island in mind, featuring many local pieces and touches throughout, including a handcrafted canoe from a local Beaver Island craftsman. A conservation easement to the west ensures the privacy of this setting for good. The 2,940 square feet of finished living space is supported by systems built for the demands of Up North living: dual propane furnaces, whole-house air conditioning, an automatic backup generator, and a deep well delivering pure, filter-free water. The roof is a heavy-duty Galvalume metal system. Beaver Island itself is part of the story: one of a small number of certified Dark Sky Sanctuaries in the world, prized for its star-filled skies and Northern Lights visibility, and a beloved Great Lakes sailing destination served by two marinas and two airports. This home could not be replicated today anywhere near the list price, a rare opportunity to own a true architectural achievement on one of the Great Lakes' most storied islands.

37659 Kings Highway, Beaver Island
$525,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1946275 MLS ⋅ Fox Pointe Trail BLDG.
Welcome to Huckleberry Hill, a beautifully maintained waterfront retreat nestled on 10 private acres overlooking the tranquil waters of Fox Lake. With approximately 233 feet of lake frontage, this exceptional Beaver Island property offers a rare combination of privacy, natural beauty, and thoughtful updates. Surrounded by hardwood forests, native wetlands, and abundant wildlife, Huckleberry Hill is a nature lover's dream. Wild huckleberries and cranberries flourish throughout the landscape, while bald eagles soar overhead, loons call across the water, and turtles bask along the shoreline. Fox Lake is known for excellent fishing opportunities, including largemouth bass, walleye, and bluegill. Whether you're birdwatching from the porch, casting a line from the dock, or kayaking along the shoreline, every day offers a deeper connection to the natural beauty of Beaver Island. The main residence features two bedrooms, one bathroom, and an inviting screened porch that feels suspended among the treetops. This peaceful outdoor living space is the perfect place to enjoy morning coffee and take in beautiful lake views. Inside, quality craftsmanship and abundant windows fill the home with natural light while framing picturesque views of the surrounding woods and water. Recent improvements include several new windows, enhancing comfort and efficiency. A charming guest house tucked along the wooded walkway offers private accommodations for family and friends. Cozy and welcoming, it provides guests with their own peaceful retreat while enjoying the beauty of the property. Recent updates include a newly installed well and a new multi-section dock, providing convenient access to the lake for swimming, fishing, kayaking, paddleboarding, and exploring Fox Lake. From its handcrafted character and thoughtful improvements to its extraordinary setting, Huckleberry Hill is more than a home—it's a place to slow down, reconnect, and create lasting memories. Beaver Island at it's finest

28525 Fox Pointe Trail, Beaver Island
$175,000
1945883 MLS ⋅ Metes And Bounds BLDG.
Rare opportunity to own 80 acres on beautiful Beaver Island, comprised of two adjoining 40-acre parcels in the island’s peaceful northern region. Tucked away in a quiet, natural setting, this expansive property offers the privacy, wildlife, and wooded beauty that make Beaver Island such a special Northern Michigan destination. With close proximity to St. James, the Beaver Island Harbor Lighthouse, and island amenities while still maintaining a secluded feel, the property offers endless possibilities for recreation, a seasonal getaway, future development, or long-term investment. Explore miles of natural beauty, enjoy the tranquility of island living, and experience the unmatched charm of Michigan’s largest island from this exceptional acreage offering.

Kings Highway, Beaver Island
$60,000
1945562 MLS ⋅ N/A BLDG.
Escape the mainland hustle and build your vision on "America’s Emerald Isle" with this rare 1.6-acre parcel located just south of downtown St. James. Situated on King's Highway—the island's main thoroughfare—this premium Harbor District property offers the ultimate blend of immediate town convenience and rugged, wooded privacy. Unlike low-lying lots, this canvas is high and dry, boasting beautiful, rolling topography blanketed by mature hardwood trees. Because it is uniquely zoned for both commercial and residential use, the possibilities are endless. You can design the ultimate "ferry-to-firepit" retreat, stepping off the boat in town and walking straight to a private cabin nestled in the woods to enjoy Beaver Island's International Dark Sky Sanctuary. Alternatively, you can capitalize on the high visibility and constant traffic flow to build an entrepreneur's dream, whether that is a boutique storefront, local outfitter, or a mixed-use live/work space. If you are ready to trade the mainland for island time, this property offers the rare opportunity to bring that vision to life.

TBD Kings Highway, Beaver Island
$115,000
1944889 MLS ⋅ N/A BLDG.
Beautiful sandy lakefront lot on the south side of Lake Geneserath with a bonus lot on the interior of the drive. These parcels offer an elevated building site which would allow for stunning northwest views of the lake allowing you to take in the sunset every night. This parcel includes two lots with a deeded access to Lot 63 on Cable's Bay - a shared access for the owners of the Cable Bay Plat. With 150' of frontage on Lake Geneserath and access to sandy shores on Lake Michigan right across the road, you would have the best of both worlds - warm protected waters of an inland lake + a sandy beach on the shores of Lake Michigan. You won't want to miss this incredible opportunity.

Lots 56 & 57 Spaulding Drive, Beaver Island
$495,000
6 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1944577 MLS ⋅ Port St. James BLDG.
Perfectly situated on the corner of White Cedar Trail and Hemlock Trail, this spacious six-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers comfort, functionality, and the peaceful beauty of Northern Michigan living. Set on four lots (702, 703, 704, and 705), the property spans an impressive 298’ x 180’ and the house provides 2,626 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space as well as a large one car garage. At the heart of the home is the large, modern kitchen - one of the owners favorite features. With abundant cupboard space, two sinks, and plenty of room to move around - it’s ideal for cooking, gathering, and everyday living. The adjacent dining area creates the perfect space for family meals and entertaining. Each of the six bedrooms is generously sized and includes its own sink, adding a level of convenience that makes daily routines much easier. The all-glass, four-season porch stretches across the entire southwest side of the home, filling the space with natural light and beautiful views year-round. Just beyond, the large back deck is the perfect place to relax and enjoy summer evenings. From the deck you can often hear loons flying overhead as they travel between Lake Michigan and Font Lake - along with songbirds, woodpeckers, turkeys, grouse, and even the occasional owl or eagle. The pellet stove on the front porch offers a cozy and efficient way to help heat the home on cooler evenings. The backyard has supported thriving gardens for years. Some of the home's additional features are built-in storage shelving, a backyard floodlight, and a water softener with bypass for raw well water for the grass and/or garden. Located just north of the Font Lake boat launch, only ¾ mile from the Association beaches on Donegal Bay and 1.5 miles from mid-town St. James, this home offers the perfect balance of privacy, recreation, and convenience.

27646 White Cedar Drive, Beaver Island
$45,000
1941357 MLS ⋅ Wicklow Beach BLDG.
Gently rolling hills and towering hardwoods set the tone for this serene woodland retreat. This beautiful acreage is ready to bring your vision to life, with a driveway and building site already cleared, an open canvas tucked into nature. Located just south of the Bill Wagner Campground, it’s an easy walk or bike ride to public access along the shores of Lake Michigan. Nearby trails offer year-round recreation, perfect for hiking, exploring, birding, or snowmobiling through the surrounding landscape. Hundreds of acres of bordering state land line the western boundary, creating a private, scenic setting ideal for a hunting camp, weekend getaway, or secluded homestead surrounded by the quiet beauty of the forest.

TBD East Side Drive, Beaver Island
$135,000
1941305 MLS ⋅ N/A BLDG.
Hemlock Point ~ once you enter this drive, it will take your breath away. There is nothing else quite like this special place on Beaver Island. The refreshing breezes that come off the lake, the solitude provided by the crest of state owned land on the north side of the lake... It is a fisherman's paradise and a wonderful retreat for those who enjoy the sounds of nature. Just to the south is the Cable's Creek Preserve, providing direct public access to sandy Lake Michigan shores. This package consists of Lots 13, 14, & 15. The lots are on the north side of the peninsula. With 297' of frontage on Lake Geneserath, you will have plenty of flexibility. Offering privacy or the option to build multiple homes. Definitely a special property to bring your dreams to life!

TBD Whitetail Trail, Beaver Island
$275,000
1940242 MLS ⋅ N/A BLDG.
Stunning Lake Michigan frontage. With 225' of private mixed sand and rock beach, this 2.5 acre property is a dream site for your island home. Located on Mrs. Reddings Trail, there is seclusion and privacy with just a 15 minute drive into town. Towering hardwood and pine mix with sunset views. A driveway and building site have already been cleared and this gem is ready for your next build!

32010 Mrs Reddings Trail, Beaver Island
$225,000
1938360 MLS ⋅ N/A BLDG.
Gorgeous bay front property located just south of Left's Point. This is a very deep lot that is covered in pines and hardwoods. There is a slow rise from the waterfront to a dune overlooking the bay with sunset views. Old growth trees, a vernal pond, multiple dune plateaus, and a beach that allows beach combing, rock hunting, sitting and enjoying the sunset at the end of the day. There is electric available at the road. This lot is part of a bird sanctuary that allows bird enthusiasts to enjoy the luxury of hearing and seeing these beauties! The water is clear, shallow for a long distance, with a gradual depth for swimming. This is the most beautiful lot on the island!

TBD Mrs Reddings Trail, Beaver Island
$25,000
1934303 MLS ⋅ Port St. James Association BLDG.
Secluded location near the end of Allen's Lakeview Road. Offering Lots 867 & 868 at one low price! Located in the Port St. James Association. (you can find more information on this association on the PSJ website - www.psja.org) This property is just few steps away from the Kuebler Trail, which also provides Lake Michigan access at McCauley's Point where you can enjoy the beautiful sand beach and sunsets. Picturesque rolling hills and almost an acre to build your island retreat.

TBD Allens Lakeview, Beaver Island
$78,000
1931407 MLS ⋅ Kilty's Point Condomunium BLDG.
Offering a beautiful waterfront setting for your island dream home. Unit 8 of Kilty's Point is located on the east side of the island. This property has much to offer with 125' of Lake Michigan frontage. The lot consists of 1.5 wooded acres with a portion of the property on the inland side of the road. Rocky shores and a woodland retreat most fitting for a nature lover. There is a sandy beach public access just 1/2 mile down the road. Perfect piece of paradise.

TBD East Side Drive, Beaver Island
Start Your Search