Refine Search
Map
Sort by
38493 Indian Woods, Beaver Island
$245,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1951331 MLS ⋅ Port St. James BLDG.
Tucked among the trees in the desirable Port of St. James, this charming two-bedroom, one-bath cottage offers a peaceful Beaver Island retreat just a short walk from the shores of Lake Michigan and approximately one mile from beautiful Donegal Bay. Situated on two lots, the property offers a wonderful sense of privacy and room to enjoy the surrounding island landscape. Inside, the home feels bright, comfortable, and welcoming, with an open living area, abundant windows, and a cozy wood stove creating the perfect gathering space after a day at the beach or exploring the island. The kitchen and dining areas flow easily into the living space, while large windows bring in natural light and views of the surrounding woods. The cottage has also benefited from several significant improvements, including anew septic system installed in 2019, updated flooring, a new roof in 2025, and all-new windows in 2026, professionally installed by Greenwald - a respected Beaver Island contractor. The property is served by a shallow well. Whether you're looking for a seasonal island getaway, vacation rental opportunity, or a simple year-round home surrounded by nature, this inviting cottage offers an appealing combination of location, character, and important recent updates - all within easy reach of some of Beaver Island's most beautiful LakeMichigan shoreline.

38493 Indian Woods, Beaver Island
26625 Chipmunk Trail, Beaver Island
$2,300,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 1950749 MLS ⋅ N/A BLDG.
Touches of elegance and the feeling of lifetimes preserved give this remarkable Lake Michigan home a character all its own. Set along 100 feet of sandy frontage on Beaver Island’s north shore, the home blends timeless architectural details with extraordinary craftsmanship and thoughtful design. Coffered ceilings, custom hardwood cabinetry, marble countertops, solid maple and tile flooring, restored antique lighting, custom stained glass, and collected architectural pieces create a home that simply cannot be replicated. The kitchen is equally distinctive, with an antique steel ceiling, generous workspace, large bar, and appliances cleverly tucked into unfitted cabinetry. And then there is the sunroom. Running the length of the home along the Lake Michigan side, this light-filled space feels as though it stepped straight out of Savannah, Georgia, with doors from the adjoining rooms opening toward the waterfront beyond. Designed for comfortable main-floor living, the primary suite and two beautifully finished bedrooms are all on the first floor, while two additional bedroom suites upstairs provide privacy for family and guests. Four bedrooms feature ensuite baths, and a lake-view loft creates another inviting place to gather or retreat. Comfort and efficiency were equally considered, with radiant in-floor heat, geothermal heating and cooling, two wood stoves, plus wind and solar power with battery storage. This home also is protected by SimpliSafe. The lower level offers abundant storage and dedicated creative spaces, including a wood shop, stained-glass studio, and paint studio. Outside, 100 feet of sandy Lake Michigan shoreline becomes part of everyday life. Private and tucked away, yet just minutes from town and the Beaver Island Lodge, this is a place to step into another world without giving up convenience. A home with a story, a shoreline of your own, and an island life waiting to be lived. Your island home awaits.

26625 Chipmunk Trail, Beaver Island
37659 Kings Highway, Beaver Island
$975,000
4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 1947510 MLS ⋅ N/A BLDG.
Set on 5.2 private, wooded acres at the southern edge of St. James on Beaver Island, this home is a masterwork of western lodge architecture translated for Northern Michigan living. Built by island-renowned builder Ron Wojan, with steel-reinforced timber framing throughout, it was constructed to endure. Florida pine paneling, reclaimed lumber flooring worn to a rich, storied patina, and cedar-lined closets speak to a level of craftsmanship rarely found today. Each of the four bedrooms enjoys its own en-suite bath. A covered entry welcomes you off the circular drive. Out back, the true showpiece: a 12' by 43' screened porch spanning the full width of the home, anchored by a dining area on one end and a built-in grilling station on the other, made for entertaining against the island backdrop. Inside, custom cabinetry glows with automatic backlighting, and the home was crafted with Beaver Island in mind, featuring many local pieces and touches throughout, including a handcrafted canoe from a local Beaver Island craftsman. A conservation easement to the west ensures the privacy of this setting for good. The 2,940 square feet of finished living space is supported by systems built for the demands of Up North living: dual propane furnaces, whole-house air conditioning, an automatic backup generator, and a deep well delivering pure, filter-free water. The roof is a heavy-duty Galvalume metal system. Beaver Island itself is part of the story: one of a small number of certified Dark Sky Sanctuaries in the world, prized for its star-filled skies and Northern Lights visibility, and a beloved Great Lakes sailing destination served by two marinas and two airports. This home could not be replicated today anywhere near the list price, a rare opportunity to own a true architectural achievement on one of the Great Lakes' most storied islands.

37659 Kings Highway, Beaver Island
28525 Fox Pointe Trail, Beaver Island
$499,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1946275 MLS ⋅ Fox Pointe Trail BLDG.
Welcome to Huckleberry Hill, a beautifully maintained waterfront retreat nestled on 10 private acres overlooking the tranquil waters of Fox Lake. With approximately 233 feet of lake frontage, this exceptional Beaver Island property offers a rare combination of privacy, natural beauty, and thoughtful updates. Surrounded by hardwood forests, native wetlands, and abundant wildlife, Huckleberry Hill is a nature lover's dream. Wild huckleberries and cranberries flourish throughout the landscape, while bald eagles soar overhead, loons call across the water, and turtles bask along the shoreline. Fox Lake is known for excellent fishing opportunities, including largemouth bass, walleye, and bluegill. Whether you're birdwatching from the porch, casting a line from the dock, or kayaking along the shoreline, every day offers a deeper connection to the natural beauty of Beaver Island. The main residence features two bedrooms, one bathroom, and an inviting screened porch that feels suspended among the treetops. This peaceful outdoor living space is the perfect place to enjoy morning coffee and take in beautiful lake views. Inside, quality craftsmanship and abundant windows fill the home with natural light while framing picturesque views of the surrounding woods and water. Recent improvements include several new windows, enhancing comfort and efficiency. A charming guest house tucked along the wooded walkway offers private accommodations for family and friends. Cozy and welcoming, it provides guests with their own peaceful retreat while enjoying the beauty of the property. Recent updates include a newly installed well and a new multi-section dock, providing convenient access to the lake for swimming, fishing, kayaking, paddleboarding, and exploring Fox Lake. From its handcrafted character and thoughtful improvements to its extraordinary setting, Huckleberry Hill is more than a home—it's a place to slow down, reconnect, and create lasting memories. Beaver Island at it's finest

28525 Fox Pointe Trail, Beaver Island
27646 White Cedar Drive, Beaver Island
$400,000
6 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1944577 MLS ⋅ Port St. James BLDG.
Perfectly situated on the corner of White Cedar Trail and Hemlock Trail, this spacious six-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers comfort, functionality, and the peaceful beauty of Northern Michigan living. Set on four lots (702, 703, 704, and 705), the property spans an impressive 298’ x 180’ and the house provides 2,626 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space as well as a large one car garage. At the heart of the home is the large, modern kitchen - one of the owners favorite features. With abundant cupboard space, two sinks, and plenty of room to move around - it’s ideal for cooking, gathering, and everyday living. The adjacent dining area creates the perfect space for family meals and entertaining. Each of the six bedrooms is generously sized and includes its own sink, adding a level of convenience that makes daily routines much easier. The all-glass, four-season porch stretches across the entire southwest side of the home, filling the space with natural light and beautiful views year-round. Just beyond, the large back deck is the perfect place to relax and enjoy summer evenings. From the deck you can often hear loons flying overhead as they travel between Lake Michigan and Font Lake - along with songbirds, woodpeckers, turkeys, grouse, and even the occasional owl or eagle. The pellet stove on the front porch offers a cozy and efficient way to help heat the home on cooler evenings. The backyard has supported thriving gardens for years. Some of the home's additional features are built-in storage shelving, a backyard floodlight, and a water softener with bypass for raw well water for the grass and/or garden. Located just north of the Font Lake boat launch, only ¾ mile from the Association beaches on Donegal Bay and 1.5 miles from mid-town St. James, this home offers the perfect balance of privacy, recreation, and convenience.

27646 White Cedar Drive, Beaver Island

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!